The i-frame and the s-frame: How focusing on individual-level solutions has led behavioral public policy astray
By Nick Chater and George Loewenstein
The article argues that behavioral science has overemphasized individual-level fixes, which deliver modest results and distract from needed systemic solutions. It calls for a shift toward using behavioral insights to design and advance broad, system-level policy change.

What is the article about?
Chater and Loewenstein distinguish between two primary approaches to addressing societal problems: the individual-frame (i-frame) and the system-frame (s-frame). The i-frame focuses primarily on individuals, their thoughts, and behaviors. I-frame policies, often associated with "nudges," aim to make subtle adjustments to the choice architecture (e.g., a prompt to save more for retirement) to help individuals make better decisions without fundamentally changing the rules of the game. The s-frame focuses on modifying the overall system, including rules, norms, institutions, regulation, and taxation.
Why is the current focus on the i-frame problematic?
First, i-frame interventions often yield disappointingly modest, small, or null results. Second, they deflect attention and political support away from much-needed s-frame policies. Highlighting the i-frame is a long-established tactic of corporate opponents of concerted systemic action, who seek to frame societal problems as issues of individual weakness and responsibility.
The problem is exemplified by the authors with several case studies, one of them is obesity: behavioral scientists enthusiastically engaged with i-frame solutions for obesity, such as specialized calorie labeling, incentives for weight loss, and promoting exercise. However, these approaches have been disappointing; for instance, people often regain weight once financial incentives are removed, and incentives to exercise have not reliably demonstrated a measurable impact on actual weight. While publicly promoting this i-frame perspective (i.e., focusing on personal responsibility), the food industry relentlessly lobbies at the s-frame level to maintain or modify laws and regulations to their advantage, thereby undermining effective systemic reforms like a sugar tax.
How can behavioral science shift its focus toward an s-frame behavioral public policy?
Instead of seeking quick i-frame fixes, behavioral science researchers should use their skills to help increase public support for s-frame policies. Such a shift requires:
- Seeing the problem: Understanding when and why people perceive an issue as urgent enough to warrant attention and policy solutions.
- Increasing public policy support: Applying psychological insights to design policies that garner public support and overcome people’s preference to maintain their current situation. This includes recognizing that people adapt quickly to effective s-frame policies once implemented.
- Improving policy design: Ensuring that s-frame policies are "ergonomic" (i.e., easy to understand and comply with). This also includes improving the policy-making process itself, addressing issues like overconfidence or groupthink among policymakers.
- Understanding and reversing industry exploitation: Using psychological knowledge to understand how industry exploits human psychology (e.g., industries including cigarettes and gambling that partially depend on “hooking” consumers).
- S-frame changes that improve i-frame decision making: Fundamentally changing the rules of the game (e.g., eliminating conflicts of interest between professionals and their clients) is often more powerful than merely modifying choice architecture.
Does this mean that i-frame interventions are obsolete?
No, according to the authors individual-level research remains crucial to informing s-frame policy. After all, systems work by influencing individuals, and their design, operation, and impact rely heavily on human psychology.
Interested to learn more?
Chater, N., & Loewenstein, G. (2023). The i-frame and the s-frame: How focusing on individual-level solutions has led behavioral public policy astray. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 46, e147.