Event details from: L&M Seminar: Norbert Schwartz & Daphna Oyserman (USC Dornsife)

Date
20 December 2022
Time
15:30 – 17:00

Introduction

From our own thoughts to others’ claims, ideas can feel right or wrong before we have thought through the details or reviewed relevant evidence. We trace these intuitive assessments to the interplay of rational truth criteria and their ecologically valid, but fallible, association with metacognitive experiences. When people evaluate truth, they usually rely on a subset of five criteria: Is it compatible with other things I believe? Is it internally consistent? Does it tell a plausible story? Does it come from a credible source? Are there many supporting arguments? Do others think so as well? Each criterion can be evaluated by drawing on relevant details (an effortful analytic strategy) or by attending to the ease with which the content can be processed (a less effortful intuitive strategy). Claims that are incompatible with other knowledge, internally inconsistent, unfamiliar, and so on, are processed less fluently, which makes (dis)fluency an experiential indicator of whether the idea is likely to be right. But people are generally more sensitive to their feelings than to the source of their feelings and misread concurrent incidental experiences as bearing on their focal thoughts. As a result, any variable that affects the metacognitive experience –from the cultural familiarity of the context to message and presentation variables-- can influence whether an idea feels right, with downstream consequences for reasoning and behavior. We review select findings from this research program.

General information

If you are interested in joining this seminar, please send an email to the secretariat of the Amsterdam Business School at secbs-abs@uva.nl.